Cyrano
18. "RE: Act 1"
In response to
message #0
ルL
|
The first Act is
dull and slow, with a great detail of the setting, motion, and
description of characters. Besides, Act 1 is filled with a lot
of unimportant characters like some porter, some cavaliers, and
some guardsmans. For a reader who does not actually sees the
play, it is very confusing to read along when the characters are
coming up here and there.
Until the later part of Act 1, the play starts to follow a
structure. The spot light is shined on Cyrano. The story shows
Cyrano's extraordinary abilities, and how brave and confident
Cyrano is to guard his friend home. Cyrano knows he will need to
fight a hundred men on the way to his friend's house, but he
shows no fear. This is what we like to call "cool".
The Act 1 did a reasonable job on explaining the
relationships between the main characters like Cyrano, Roxane,
and Christian. It also gives details about Roxane by casual
conversation between Christian and his friend. Besides, the
story incorporates a great work of poetry into the play. The
poetry from Cyrano shows how intelligent Cyrano is, and at the
same time, increases the amount of dramatic elements to the
play.
ルL
|
ルL
|
|
|
chunwaihung
Member since Apr-6-04
27 posts |
May-12-04, 10:46 PM (PST) |

|
14. "RE: Cyrano Act 1"
In response to
message #0
ルL
|
The Act 1 didn't give me
good impressions. It seems long and boring. The most dramatic part seems
to be the fight with ballade. I understand that part of the play is
especially difficult to write, but the content of the ballade is not so
interesting to me.
The part that interests me the most is the presence of Roxane. The
love relationship in the play is more interesting and easier to
understand than the ballade formed during a fight. Moreover, the Act
successfully showed the readers how ¨cool。e Cyrano is.
I suppose it is necessary to describe things in great detail in the
first Act, so the actual play on the theatre floor will more accurately
reveal the writer。ヨs ideas.
ルL
|
|
ルL
"RE: Cyrano Act 2"
In response to
message #0
ルL
|
Act 2 is where the
tragedy begins.
In fact, I have a friend named Roxane, and I have a friend named
Christian. The Roxane I know was fairly pretty, and Roxane and
Christian together made a funny picture in my mind.
Anyway, for Act 2, the whole story is much clearer. There is a
clear objective, or we should say a clear key object - the
pretty girl Roxane. The story becomes easier to understand
because the love relationship is what everyone is familiar with.
|
|
|
|
Subject: "RE: Act 3" |
Act 3 contains the balcony scene, in which Christian tried to talk to
Roxane without the help from Cyrano. It turned out that Christian was not
good at words at all, and Roxane was disappointed and decided to leave
Christian.
Despite the strong affection of Cyrano towards Roxane, Cyrano rescued
Christian by hiding under the balcony and spoke for Christian. Roxane was
once again fallen in love with Christian by the loving words coming from
Cyrano's mouth.
In Act 3, Roxane showed how she loved the letters written from Cyrano
under the name of Christian. She recited all the letters she received,
which showed how she loved the letters from Cyrano.
Towards the end of Act 3, De Guiche was brought into the play. Under
his order, Cyrano and Christian was sent to the war to fight the enemies.
Act 3 showed how Roxane reacted to such a situation. She cared only for
Christian, and was less concern about Cyrano.
ルL
|
Cyrano was kind of cool. I may not be able to do what he did
towards Roxane. I am the kind of person who will try everything
to get what I want. In this case, the pretty girl, Roxane.
It is like a game, you either end up losing or you win.
 |
|
|
|
chunwaihung
Member since Apr-6-04
32 posts |
May-15-04, 03:39 PM (PST) |

|
13. "RE: Act 4"
In response to
message #0
設
|
The fourth Act is the
climax of the play, especially when Roxane arrived at the middle of the
war. Roxane came for her love Christian, and her action was the ultimate
expression of love a woman could make.
At the beginning of the play, Cyrano and others were starving. They
were surrounded by their enemies. Under such harsh conditions, Cyrano
still kept writing and sending out letters to Roxane everyday. This
shows the depth of Cyrano’s love towards Roxane, and the way he was
willing to risk his life only for the pleasure of Roxane by reading a
letter.
In the play, in addition to Christian and Cyrano, there was also a De
Guiche who loved Roxane deep enough that he was willing to stay in the
battlefield to protect Roxane. This contributes to the overall conflict
of the play, in which the three people who loved Roxane were willing to
die for her.
I agree with Ashley that the writer didn’t write much about Roxane’s
thoughts or similar things like that. The story is generally too heroic
and dramatic.
|
|
chunwaihung
Member since Apr-6-04
34 posts |
May-15-04, 04:04 PM (PST) |

|
11. "RE: Act 5"
In response to
message #0
設
|
Roxane: ¨It was you.。イ
Cyrano: ¨No, no, Roxane, no!。イ (189)
After all 15 years, at the edge of death, what is Cyrano so afraid
of? He was brave enough to fight a war, to die from starvation, and to
risk his life to send letters (the most difficult one), but he dared not
to tell his heart in front of the girl he loved.
In Act 5, Roxane still carried the last letter from the dead body of
Christian. This showed how strong she loved Christian by wrongly
assuming that the letter was written from Christian. More dramatic than
that is Cyrano could still recite what he wrote to Roxane 15 years ago
in the middle of the dark.
Nonetheless, Cyrano reminds a hero even when he dies. He died with
his blade, and said ¨I fight on! I fight on! I fight on!。イ (195)in the
second to the last page. The play ends with the end of Cyrano」セs life,
which is an appropriate arrangement. Beside, it also reinforces the
heroic character of Cyrano.
設
|
|
chunwaihung
Member since Apr-6-04
35 posts |
May-15-04, 04:07 PM (PST) |

|
7. "RE: Cyrano Act 5"
In response to
message #0
設
|
It doesn」セt make much sense
a brave person like Cyrano is afraid of love. I think such nonsense is
merely an dramatic element for the play. In other words, it seems more
like a play for the audiences than a story. Anyway, a play doesn」セt have
to make much sense.
The whole play would be more attractive if the book cover is replaced
with a more handsome looking male with a pretty looking female. In other
words, the book cover we have only tells us, ¨This is an old play, and
you need to enjoy it.。e How come the cover is only brown and white? We
can have more colorful cover, which at least will make me think this is
a beloved and popular story.
I drew many pictures on the book while I was reading the book. I have
drawings on almost every page of the book. By doing this, it helps me
visualize what。ヨs going on in the book. I am a person who is better with
pictures than words. When I flip to a page, and I see the picture I
drew, I will remember what was on that part of the play 愺 the setting,
the character, and the actions.
|
|
|